Wikia

Geek Feminism Wiki

Google+ name policy debate

Talk0
1,064pages on
this wiki

In July 2011, Google+ started suspending user accounts for using pseudonyms or other names which violated their community standards.

This became the major part of the online pseudonym discussion called Nymwars.

Summary of the problem Edit

Many people use names online which do not match their government-issued ID, whether for reasons of privacy, to avoid harassment or stereotyping, or for many other reasons. We have documented many reasons why people might want to be pseudonymous at Who is harmed by a "Real Names" policy? Specific to this wiki, it's worth noting that women are disproportionately affected by a policy like this.

In addition to Google+'s policy being misguided and harmful to many users, the implementation of the policy was also problematic, leading to many users being incorrectly suspended or having difficulty getting their accounts back.

Timeline of events Edit

(Just an overview.)

  • July 5th, 2011 -- Google+ field trial launched
  • July 8th, 2011 -- early account suspensions, initial press/blog coverage
  • July 22nd, 2011 -- mass account suspensions, widespread press/blog coverage
  • July 25th, 2011 -- statement from Bradley Horowitz, Google VP Product, promising better process/implementation

Reasons given (or suggested) for the policy Edit

Anti-spam Edit

The Google+ Community Standards say, "To help fight spam and prevent fake profiles, use the name your friends, family or co-workers usually call you."

However, no particular naming policy can prevent spam. If a policy requires real(-looking) names, then spammers will simply give themselves names that pass the policy.

Google already knows that algorithmic detection (possibly assisted by user flagging) is the best way to prevent spam, and that's what they use in web search and in GMail.

To prevent fake profiles/impersonation Edit

This is already covered elsewhere in the community standards ("Do not use our products to impersonate other people.") and is grounds for suspension in any case. Requiring names that look a certain way does not actually give any additional protection against this.

To help people find you Edit

People can most easily find you under the name you're known by. For many people, this is not the name on their ID, or may not look like a WASP name.

Types of accounts suspended Edit

The following types of accounts have been documented as being suspended. Most of these categories are, arguably, wrongful suspensions:

Other notes regarding suspensions and exemptions Edit

  • Some people were suspended multiple times, eg. CZ Unit
  • Google SVP of Social, Vic Gundotra, has admitted that the name he uses is not what appears on his ID, yet is permitted on Google+.
  • Celebrities such as Lady Gaga and 50 Cent are permitted/have not been suspended.

Legal issues Edit

There is some argument that Google+'s policies may be illegal.

Europe Edit

Google's policies may break European privacy law.

Jay Blanc has been posting extensively about this:

The Register reports that the UK's Information Commissioner's Office is "looking into it".

US Edit

Under US law:

One may be employed, do business, and enter into other contracts, and sue and be sued under any name they choose at will (Lindon v. First National Bank 10 F. 894, Coppage v. Kansas 236 U.S. 1, In re McUlta 189 F. 250).
Such a change carries exactly the same legal weight as a court-decreed name change as long as it is not done with fraudulent intent (In re McUlta 189 F. 250, Christianson v. King County 196 F. 791, United States v. McKay 2 F.2d 257).

Other common law countries Edit

Most other common law countries (Australia, Canada, etc) have similar laws regarding use of a name other than what is on your government ID, i.e. that you can legally use any name you choose, as long as you're not doing so for fraudulent purposes.

Responses and commentary Edit

RoundupsEdit

Nymwars has attracted an enormous amount of attention from the media and bloggers. Roundups include:

ResourcesEdit

On this wiki: Pseudonymity, Outing, Real name, Wallet name, Who is harmed by a "Real Names" policy?

Elsewhere: Anti-pseudonym bingo

Around Wikia's network

Random Wiki